When it comes to tool bags vs tool boxes there are a few important things to consider before making a decision. Both have their strengths and weaknesses but one is better overall. In this post we’ll get into the main things to examine when determining which is best for you.
Tool Box: When it comes to organization tool boxes aren’t as versatile as tool bags. They generally have one big compartment that everything is thrown inside of. A lot of times they’ll have a shelf that separates the box into one big compartment and one small one. The top one will be for smaller things like drill bits, sockets etc. the bottom section is where you’ll have all your hand tools and larger items. Depending on how large the tool box is you might be able to throw power tools in there as well
Tool Bag: You’ll find a wider variety of tool bags that are all different. Some will just have one large compartment which is good if you just want to use it for power tools. Other ones will have many pockets so that you can place each tool in its own spot. Having that ability makes it a lot easier and quicker to find the specific tool you need. With tool bags you’ll also have a lot of different options like tool totes (which are tool bags that are open at the top) and rolling tool bags. Tool bags make organization a lot easier and allow you to be more efficient.
Winner: Tool Bag
Tool Box: The ability to transport your tools from your home to your car or from your car to work is very important, especially if you use your tools outside of your house. Most tool boxes are heavy-duty which will make them heavier than a tool bag. That’ll make it a little more difficult to move it around. Tool boxes are made of a thicker and more rigid material which make them harder to fit in smaller spaces like the trunk of your car or in a gang box at work.
Tool Bag: The ability to take your tool bag with you from one location to another is a lot easier. In the market you have a wider variety of different types of tool bags. Some bags have wheels, some have shoulder straps, and others just have a handle that you can carry it with. Tool bags are a lot more lightweight which will be critical when you start filling it up with a lot of tools. They’re also a lot more compact and malleable which make it easier to fit in tighter spaces.
Winner: Tool Bag
Tool Box: Tool boxes are very durable and heavy-duty. Most tool boxes are made of metal or a strong plastic material. Because of that material a lot of tool boxes are waterproof and can withstand being out in the rain. The disadvantage of a tool box in this category is that its more likely to get scratched and dinged up. If you drop it on the floor than you’re more than likely going to dent it and mess up one of the corners.
Tool Bag: Tool bags are generally made from fabric, leather, cotton, or other materials. These materials have a higher probability or getting ripped over time depending on how much you take care of it. Because of the materials they’re made out of they’re generally not waterproof; you will find some bags that are but that’s not the norm. Some bags are built with an internal metal frame that gives the bag extra support. Rolling tool bags are built with a stronger framework that make the bag more durable. Overall I’d say tool boxes are more durable but you can find some tool bags that will hold their own.
Winner: Tool Box
Size & Weight
Tool Box: Tool boxes are a lot bulkier and heavier than tool bags; once you add your tools in them it makes them that much heavier. They come an all different shapes and sizes so it just depends on what you’re looking for. Tool boxes are great for storage, its perfect if you’re planning to keep it in one place the whole time.
Tool Bag: Tool bags are made to be a lot smaller and lightweight. This makes it easier to move your tools around anywhere you need them; even if you don’t have many tools it makes it easier to maneuver them in a tool bag rather than a tool box. Size & Weight goes hand in hand with portability and allows you to be more mobile with your tool set.
Winner: Tool Bag
How will you use it?
When it comes to the tool bag vs tool box debate it ultimately depends on how you’re planning to use it. If you need one for work or just plan to carry it with you everywhere than I’d definitely recommend getting a tool bag. If you plan to just keep it sitting in your garage or in a workshop than a tool box would be just fine for that. There are many variations of tool bags and tool boxes; I’ll be digging deeper into more specific tool bags and tool boxes and let you know which I think are the best.